Wednesday, February 24, 2016

125 Rebuttals, 1A and 1B

This is the second post in a (hopefully quite long and interesting) series of rebuttals against this particular webpage.

Since we discussed point 1 yesterday, I'm going to glance over 1a and 1b here, before starting into the next argument.  I really hope the author isn't counting each of these individually as arguments, because that'll really shorten the overall scope of this series.

1A: The software and hardware of the cell are irreducibly complex


Well, that made my job a lot easier, and I haven't even addressed a single premise yet.  Cells do not have a disparate nature between the 'hardware' and 'software.'  The parts of the cell interact, chemically, and that's basically all that's important here.  It isn't as though DNA is some sort of computer chip, and the sequences on it are some sort of code.  The fact that it's arranged in the way it is, is due to natural processes, not some underlying operating system.  It's a false analogy, and I'll be damned if I don't at least point it out.  Again, I'm not going to pick apart this entire sub-point, so let's find the first problematic thing in the premises.  Although, all these points are rich, we'll just pick one or two for now.  I'll come back and more thoroughly pick this apart later, if anyone's interested.
3. The cell contains a genetic code which is at or very close to a global optimum for error minimization across plausible parameter space
Well, as I pointed out yesterday, it's useful to call it a code, because it acts kinda like a code.  However, the second assertion here is that it's optimized for error minimization.  This is simply incorrect.  The 'job' of the RNA is to facilitate the copying of DNA. I don't want to belabor this point terribly, but it's important.  It's not optimized to reduce errors, so to speak.  It's simply evolved to be very good at making sure segments of DNA are copied verbatim.  If it were really optimized in such a way, species would never have evolved because the DNA would never have allowed such errors to pass through.  Indeed, some of the most famous traits in almost any given species are because the RNA simply does its job, and allows 'incorrect' versions of genes to pass on.  Whether it's heterochromy or microcephaly, the RNA only cares about transcribing what its given, generally.

Now, it is important to note that the RNA does actually act as though its got some error-correcting properties, but these properties tend to check sorts of parity, making sure it creates pairs that are AT or GC, and not AC or GT for example.  It's clear the author is not talking about this kind of parity checking when we find this premise:
7. There is no reason for information processing machinery to exist without the software, and vice versa.
Again, this is not the kind of 'information processing machinery' that DNA/RNA is.  RNA is a precursor to DNA.  Also, it's a false premise, because the author hasn't given a single reason why there is no reason.   Prions are an example of a sort of organism which are evidence of how something can reproduce without the very system point 7 is arguing must exist.  Irreducible complexity requires that nothing simpler can exist, but here it is nonetheless.

For an analogy, imagine I hand you a smart phone, and tell you that the smart phone is the simplest possible phone that can exist.  If even one part of it were not there, it would not be able to do its job, or any job.  Even looking at old rotary phones, we can still see how the removal of parts, including even the number dial, still doesn't make the phone necessarily impossible to use, or even exist.

1B: Proponents of evolution believe it is necessary to get chemicals up to the point of replication before Darwinian Evolution begins.

I'll say right now, this is a fallacy of begging the question.  I'll say more things later.

Premise 1 and 2 create a false dichotomy and a false analogy.  Abiogenesis deals with how the chemical reactions ultimately gave rise to more typical forms of life, however, not everything that evolves is living.  Viruses are a clear example of this.  They do not meet the typical definitions of 'living thing,' but very clearly demonstrate how evolution can happen absent the fact of 'life.'

Similarly, the first self-replicating molecules probably didn't resemble RNA and DNA as we know them today.  RNA was likely the precursor to DNA, so to claim that RNA can't function without DNA is preposterous.  Similarly, there are processes which replicate, which are not self-replicating. Many chemical reactions happen in nature, but very few on their own.  Fire can be started by any number of reasons, it's not self-replicating in the same sense.  This is a fallacy from ambiguity, but I digress.
4. The other problem is the origin of a genetic code that can copy itself.
This isn't a problem, save for people who don't actually understand the words they are typing.  This is a fallacy of false cause.  Using another analogy, genetics can be compared to language in one useful way: the way in which languages develop.  Since I'm speaking English, I'll use English as my example. However, this argument works with most languages as well, if they are sufficiently modern.
The argument the author presents is akin to this: English is the simplest language it could ever have been, so it must have come about exactly in its current form.  Similarly, it's impossible for English to have any degrees of variation from place to place.  Looking to the evidence, we can see this is clearly not the case.  As we move backward through time, we can see that as early as a few hundred years ago, the English used by speakers at that time would be considerably different.  I don't know of any people who routinely speak in old English or middle English.

My point here is, English has slowly and steadily evolved into the language it is today.  We can also go a great deal in reverse, and see that English was indeed a simpler language in the past.  After a certain point backward in time, English ceases to be a thing, because it hasn't separated from the languages that came before it.  Going further back, we can look at ancient languages, and determine that there were languages which are incredibly simple by today's terms.  Just remember, 20 years ago Google didn't exist, and now it's a verb.

Let's think a bit further. We know, factually, that there was a time before written languages existed.  Irreducible complexity argues that cats can't possibly communicate with one another, since they don't use a verbal language with well-defined terms.  This would be impossible, since languages (like we compare the workings of DNA to) must be fully formed.  There can be no precursor, but alas, we know precursors exist in both cases.  Similarly, there probably was no 'first language' from which all other languages spawned.  Languages before writing were probably very simple - we do indeed have examples of isolated indigenous peoples using languages that would be considered very primitive by today's standards indeed.  Irreducible complexity argues that it's impossible that the same process that produced English (a language that humans speak) could possibly produce anything other than English (a language that humans speak).  In a similar way, they claim that RNA variants could not possibly have ever become DNA as we know it today, and that RNA and DNA could never have shared a common ancestor.  A language (chemical reactions) without a specific code (genes/alleles/base pairs/etc) could not possibly exist.

Addressing the next few points, point 4a is an argument from authority (rather than arguing from any evidence, he says that people think a certain way therefore one of them must be right - also a false dichotomy, since he's barring the idea that both he and the strawman he's attacking could be wrong).
5. “We now feel compelled to abandon compositional inheritance as a jumping board toward real units of evolution.”
5 is a quote from somewhere, probably out of context, possibly just made up as a strawman.
6. As one scientific theory is abandoned, often the new theory is based on faith being not 100% proven.
a. “We do not know how the transition to digitally encoded information has happened in the originally inanimate world; that is, we do not know where the RNA world might have come from, but there are strong reasons to believe that it had existed.”
6 asserts that scientific theories are abandoned, when in fact this hardly ever happens.  It's hard to create theories for this reason.  Usually they're simply expounded upon or corrected with further observation.  The author lacks that vital point, observation and evidence of his own point.

7. The metabolism-first scenario cannot work:
8. The genetics-first scenario doesn’t work:
7/8 False dichotomy: both could have developed at the same time.  Oddly enough, I'd like to know how he thinks chemical reactions can happen WITHOUT using the constituent materials. Energy is stored/used without metabolism somehow? I left out the bits that followed each point, but I think you get the idea. Oddly, I agree. Neither probably works, since they both developed together, probably.
9. Because both concepts of life’s origin are impossible, the only plausible scenario of complex life’s origin is intelligent design that implies God the best designer.
9 Intellectually dishonest false dichotomy. "Neither of the things I've proposed can be true (citation needed) therefore MY GOD is correct." Also a false premise, since it could be any god, or no god at all, or maybe some other creature did it which wasn't created by a god, like a leprechaun or race of bigfoot monsters.  Again, the point is moot, because it is quite frankly a terrible argument, if not an outright dishonest assertion. I'm going to re-write his ninth point here:
9. Because both concepts of life's origins are impossible (why?), the only plausible scenario of complex life's origin is bigfoot farted them out one afternoon that they both developed together, and not disparately.
See, this is how you create good arguments.

10. Hence God exists.
10 Is just posturing.

Alright, I know I promised point two, but I can only spend so much time per post before you quit reading. I'll pick up tomorrow where I left off today.

Peace to you all!

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

125 Rebuttals, #1

I came across this article a theist left in a twitter conversation I was having.  I reckon it couldn't hurt to have a read and at least address some.  Maybe I'll address them all. Who knows.

Argument 1: The origin of the genetic cipher.

Neat!  I bet this could be interesting.  What's the first premise? 
1.Triplet codons must be assigned to amino acids to establish a genetic cipher.  Nucleic-acid bases and amino acids don’t recognize each other directly, but have to deal via chemical intermediaries ( tRNA's and  Aminoacyl tRNA synthetase ), there is no obvious reason why particular triplets should go with particular amino acids.
Seems valid enough.  I'm not a molecular biologist, but let's see where it goes from here.

2. Other translation assignments are conceivable, but whatever cipher is established, the right amino acids must be assigned to permit polypeptide chains, which fold to active funcional proteins. Functional amino acid chains in sequence space are rare.  There are two possibilities to explain the correct assignment of the codons to the right amino acids. 
Well, we've got ourselves a possible false dichotomy (which would potentially create a fallacy in the conclusion) at the end there. I'm not even going to worry about the more technical aspects, since it seems I won't need to for this.

3. If it were a lucky accident happened by chance, luck would have  hit the jackpot  trough trial and error amongst 1.5 × 10^84 possible genetic codes . That is the number of atoms in the whole universe. That puts any real possibility of chance providing the feat out of question. Its , using  Borel's law, in the realm of impossibility. Natural selection would have to evaluate roughly 10^55 codes per second to find the one that's universal. Put simply, the chemical lottery lacks the time necessary to find the universal genetic code. 
Well, now there's a fun statement.  Thus the breakdown begins. The first two statements weren't terrible, but this one is.  First, a false premise fallacy.  We have no information on where the number of genetic 'codes' come from.  Is it supposed to be the number of different species?  Perhaps merely the number of possible combinations of x length?  I can't speculate much further with no further information, in this improperly defined premise.

Moving on to the next statement, 10^84 is probably a few orders of magnitude more atoms than are in the universe.  Let's contemplate for a moment, however, how many strands of DNA there are in the world, probably.  Wikipedia gives a much more definite number, so we'll go with that. 5*10^37 strands of DNA as an estimate.  Let's not forget, life on earth is around 3.7B years old. So, if we presume a DNA cycle on average to last a day (just pulling a number here, bacteria were the dominant thing for an incredibly long time), we'll use about 1.8 trillion days.  So, multiplying those two numbers yields a number around 9*10^46.  This number is considerably smaller, and with good reason: lots of combinations don't work.  Some combinations simply wouldn't form anything, and others lead to sterile creatures, like mules.  Naturally, these creatures won't pass on their genetic combinations, and that eliminates billions or trillions of combinations which will never form spontaneously.

Also, yes, the possible number of combinations of atoms in the universe is greater than the number of atoms in the universe.  There's only 80 numbers on a Keno board, but there's  combinations of those 80 numbers for a 10 spot ticket. That's around 6e18 combinations (e means *10^x for those of you who don't know).  So that's what you'd typically call a bad argument.  Moving on.

Genetic recombination isn't a lucky mistake, it's what happens every time something reproduces biologically.  It would be truly odd if your parents weren't nearly genetically identically to you, at least with regard to the fact that you both share human DNA sequences and not potato DNA sequences.

Borel's law isn't actually a law, so we can disregard the part of the argument that comes with it.  At best it's a false premise, because we already know things with very low probability do indeed occur, such as stars exploding into supernova.

However, if that bores you, you're in luck, because now we're tackling the last part of that statement.  These aren't really premises at all.  They're amalgamations of bad arguments. I'm going to re-quote it right here, to refresh your mind.
Put simply, the chemical lottery lacks the time necessary to find the universal genetic code.
In this one sentence, we've got a load of fallacies.  First is the false premise that the 'code' had to be 'found.'  As though it was left somewhere for a sentient thing to discover.  Abiogenesis steps in here, but even more fundamentally than that, his premise doesn't even work on how the DNA came to be. In fact, his premise starts far after that.  The chemical reactions that eventually led to something like RNA which can self-replicate don't require being 'found.'  They happen as simply as baking soda reacts with vinegar, literally a chemical reaction.  Remember, his first premise has a few flaws too, but I don't want to keep you here all day.
4. We know that minds do invent languages, codes, translation systems, ciphers, and complex, specified information all the time. 
This is a conflation of the definitions of 'code.' Anyone who is familiar in the least with molecular biology knows that the code we assign to DNA is not the same thing as what's actually going on between those pairs.  It's useful for describing it, but the 'language' the DNA speaks with itself is not a conscious thing.  It's a false analogy, at the very least, and a bit of intellectual dishonesty.

It's a bit like saying that a photon has some sort of code it gives to a leaf, which allows the leaf to engage in photosynthesis.  It's not a conscious thing. The sun isn't telling the leaves anything by sending sunlight, it's a simple chemical reaction.  Also, humans didn't invent physics, we discovered (through observation) the way things seem to work, which we call Laws.  In exactly the same way, we didn't invent the DNA code, we just assign various traits of it parts of language to make it easier to describe.
5. Put it in other words : The task compares to invent two languages, two alphabets, and a translation system, and the information content of a book ( for example hamlet)  being written in english translated  to chinese  in a extremely sophisticared hardware system. 
Actually, it doesn't do that at all.  To expound further, it's more like how we assign negative or positive voltages their designator of positive or negative.  We're not saying someone is consciously determining that positive and negative are intrinsic properties (and they're relative to one another anyway, but more on that later), or that it's any language to be derived from it. However, it's exceptionally useful to assign a value of 1 or 0 to either the positive or negative, so we can run computers.  Again, this analogy isn't great, but neither is his.  We're not simply transcribing some hidden language: we call it a code because it signals various things to happen.  It's not like Morse code or English, in that the bits have any specific meaning.  It's more like a flowchart, which causes reactions that build cells or cell parts.
6. The genetic code and its translation system is best explained through the action of a intelligent designer. 
 Based on what?  Now the leap is made further that there is literally some sort of transcription embedded in the DNA.  It's also not the best explanation.  The best explanation is that DNA/RNA interactions are chemical reactions, and that biology is, more or less, a giant set of physics (of which chemistry is a subset at this exchange).  There's no coherent message intrinsic to the process. This is how 'transcoding' errors occur, when bits interact with bits they shouldn't have.  Like when you're trying to bake a cake, but you accidentally mix everything all at once instead of one at a time.  The resultant mess may not be a cake, but it may be most of the time.  Maybe one time you add something different because you're out of something else, or leave something out because you don't have it.

It's not a great analogy, but it's simple enough to demonstrate the flaw in the premise.  A false premise, since it's got no evidence supporting it.
7. The designer is God. 
I surmise this is to be the conclusion, but it's numbered as though it's a premise.  Letting that slide, it's a false premise.  I mean, the simplest rebuttal is that perhaps it was gods. There's nothing that follows logically which requires it to be a god (humans can encode messages in DNA, after all, if we really feel like it).  Similarly, there's no foundation for asserting that it is a specific god, either.  Also, since the premises before it are incorrect/incomplete/improperly formed/false/unrelated, this conclusion is therefore also unsupported.

If you enjoy my articles, consider following me on twitter @acce245 or dropping a dollar or two at my patreon.  I will still keep the site running like always regardless.  I enjoy writing, but I wish I had more time to do it.  Let me know if there's something you want me to write about!

Peace to you all!

Monday, February 22, 2016

Free Will

So, I was on the Twitter again, as I am wont to do.  I've seen my fair share of bad arguments, but I've noticed the argument of free will a few times now.  I'm going to discard (mostly) some of the other things around this particular thing, and discuss only the things related specifically to this claim.

Let's put some perspective on this.

The basis of the claim is that the god of the bible created humans with innate free will.  Whether or not free will does indeed exist is a topic of debate which has been around for a long while.  However, I need to clarify, this is not the point of today's post.  Today we're only addressing whether or not the bible holds this point of view or not.

Now, to be clear, I'm not certain if the poster mentioned is a parody account or not, but I've heard this argument often enough.  Ergo, I shall proceed on the premise that it's his (or her) genuine opinion.

Let's pick apart the first premise.  This is almost too easy.

Now therefore fear the lord, and serve him in sincerity and truth: 
There's an interesting statement.  Basically, the first premise of this statement is that, even if you mortally fear the consequences of an action, you're still choosing to do something.  This doesn't fit the description of most definitions of free will, because it quickly becomes apparent it's not a choice.

One of my favorite analogies here is the idea of someone forcing you, at gunpoint, to dig your own grave.  Basically, you've got a shovel and you're restrained in some way.  Basically, the argument is that you somehow still have a choice, according to the tweet.  You can somehow choose to dig the grave or not.  In the same way, the picture is arguing that you have free will by forcing you to act only in accordance with the precepts of the religion.  It's certainly not free will in any real sense, because there is no choice.  With that in mind, let's move on.

and put away the gods which your fathers served on the other side of the flood, and in Egypt; and serve ye the lord.
Again, the logic comes full circle. Obey or god will kill you, then send you to hell.  If this is actually the case, it's not free will in any sense of the word.  This is entirely apart from other parts of the bible where god literally turns hearts against him, has his own will which is inviolate, or decides well in advance of your death whether or not your name is in the book of heaven, or if he puts his name on your heart.  Here's a neat post summarizing some of the same arguments.  Again, I'm not debunking the entire bible on free will, only this rather specific argument from a very small portion.

and if it seem evil unto you to serve the lord, 
False dichotomy.  It doesn't have to seem evil for me not to want to do it.  It could simply be that I don't believe in your god.  This has nothing to do with his malevolence.  Although, it's mighty handy and telling how it presupposes people are going to presume that the lord is evil.  I wonder if there's any merit to that, a god who makes you fear him so you'll serve him.  Evil is a very interesting word, however, I don't believe in the supernatural, so carrying on...

choose ye this day whom ye will serve.
Again, that doesn't leave much room for choice.  Remember, I'm being coerced into it with mortal fear of hell.  Of course, if god is all-powerful, there definitely wouldn't be a choice, because an all-knowing god certainly would know how bad it is to rule with fear, and how it limits our ability to praise him freely.  I mean, if god wants to scare us into following him, that's not really any different than simply making us to follow him without the illusion of free will. It's functionally the same thing.  It's not so different from saying that the slaves somehow had a choice in their slavery.  The choice was to submit or fear punishment.  It's literally one of the justifications for slavery, once upon a time.

whether the gods which your fathers served that were on the other side of the flood, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land ye dwell:
This is interesting also, in that it actually gives credence to their being other gods.  That's literally a thing from the cultures of that time. 'Elohim' which means chosen god, literally frames it as a choice between gods, each being equally valid.  Yahweh was Elohim of Jacob, I think, and that's where one of the divides between Islam, Christianity, and Judeaism come in.  However, let's not tarry there.  Let's remember that, according to the old testament, in this context specifically, it literally is a 'choice' in the fact that the author of this original passage probably did believe that there were other gods.  However, he clearly didn't see it as an actual choice, since he thought his god was stronger, and therefore more able to be effective at punishment in the afterlife.  Ergo, he similarly had no choice, despite the wording to follow:

but as for me and my house, we will serve the lord.
Here we can also see that this is a fact supported by various commentaries.  Similarly, it mentions Yahweh at this point. Literally, in this frame of reference, there are multiple gods which people do indeed believe exist.  Either way, it's not an argument for free will, but for conformity under threat of damnation.

Sunday, February 7, 2016

Fetuses: Are they People?

As I've been engaging with folks on twitter lately, the claim keeps resurfacing that fetuses are indeed people.



 In matter of fact, I was even linked to an article.




That's quite the interesting link, so let's break down its contents.

“The life cycle of mammals begins when a sperm enters an egg.”
One of the first arguments an anti-abortion person tends to make is that life starts at conception. In a manner of speaking, this is correct.  The argument then follows, typically, that this means that a newly-fertilized cell (literally, the earliest possible fetal diploid cell) is a person.  We'll come back to exactly why this isn't accurate, but let's consider the implications of such a notion.  This should prove a fun thought experiment.

One might ask, what are such implications?  Consider for a moment that a newborn baby is a citizen.  This means that it has exactly the same rights as any citizen.  Let's pretend for a moment, however, that every single fertilized cell is, indeed, a person.  What this means is, we now have to register them.  Forget about birth certificates: every time you have sex, we're going to have to make absolutely sure whether or not you're actually fertilizing an ovum.  Considering that most citizens in a country like the United States will get a birth certificate, how exactly would we register every single fertilized egg?  Shall we make it mandatory to have a checkup after every copulation?  I mean, we wouldn't want a woman's natural body processes like menstruation to accidentally kill a fertilized ovum which simply didn't connect with the uterine lining, now would we?  Certainly, that fertilized cell would die without some sort of law ensuring every possible fertilized ovum was guaranteed the sanctity of life!

Artist's rendition of an ovum.
Can you tell which mammal this will
develop into?
As we can see, it's probably against our best interest to give Social Security numbers to every potentially fertilized cell.  However, it's good to note that the quote isn't wrong, per se.  I mean, one could claim that the life cycle actually begins with the haploid cells in mammals, because sperm and ova are very much alive, and are also required to form the exact same person.  Is it equally murderous to let them die?  What of the millions of sperm which can't possibly fertilize any ova, being simply unlucky enough to be the first contact?  If a diploid zygote is a human, then I contest a haploid ganymete is half a human.  Although, I think assigning all men an individual social security number and life certificate for every pair of sperm is rather a stupid idea, it would be a fun maths experiment to figure out just how many numbers that would be in the average lifetime.

I think we can see, reasonably well, that a newly fertilized zygote is not, in and of itself, a human.  Even most (but not all) religious people will contend that this is not a logical argument, for some reason.  Zygotes don't contain any of the traits of a human, like a brain, appendages, organs, and so on.  It's literally no different from any other diploid cell at that point.



HIV-budding-Color.jpg



This media comes from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's 

with identification number #10000.

See that diploid cell?  That's HIV.  Interesting stuff.  Shares most of the basic physical descriptors of a mammalian zygote.  Doesn't look much like an animal.  Let's move on to the next quote.

“Fertilization is the process by which male and female haploid gametes (sperm and egg) unite to produce a genetically distinct individual.”
Again, we've basically touched on this.  That's called fertilization.  For the reasons above, I think we can see why fertilization is not a human.  Humans have very specific features that are distinct from gametes or zygotes, or even fetuses as I'll probably have to demonstrate.  I could be wrong, I've not read the entire article yet.

The genetically distinct bit, of course it's genetically distinct.  It's sharing two sets of DNA.  However, it's not correct to say that this is the point at which the DNA combines.  Again, it's not a proper mixing of DNA immediately from when the fertilization happens, we've got to get past the pronuclei stages, at least.  Literally, it's impossible that one human feature can occur for at least a day.  Also, humanoid features aren't going to happen for a few months really, but that's for another day.


“The oviduct or Fallopian tube is the anatomical region where every new life begins in mammalian species. After a long journey, the spermatozoa meet the oocyte in the specific site of the oviduct named ampulla, and fertilization takes place.” 
“Fertilization – the fusion of gametes to produce a new organism – is the culmination of a multitude of intricately regulated cellular processes.”

Again, they're both correct.  There's nothing wrong with those quotes.

“Human life begins at fertilization, the process during which a male gamete or sperm (spermatozoo developmentn) unites with a female gamete or oocyte (ovum) to form a single cell called a zygote. This highly specialized, totipotent cell marked the beginning of each of us as a unique individual.” “A zygote is the beginning of a new human being (i.e., an embryo).”
Neat.  I've no way to check this quote offhand (though google does help a bit), but I can see that the book in reference is not a highly-technical book on human development, but rather appears to be a middle or high-school level book on human anatomy and physiology.  It's okay for books like this, which are introducing basic concepts, to have simplified language.  This is how we learn everything.  It's exactly the same as if I were to start describing floating point numbers to you right now, I'd have to do so from some context you understand.  I could be wrong, but it doesn't look terribly different from the books we used in middle-school and high-school.  From what I can see, however, it is actually reasonably in-depth.

However, I'm going to use the quote anyway, to illustrate one point the original blog author seemed to miss:

(i.e., an embryo)
Again, the quote's not wrong, actually, especially in context.  However, it's been ripped from it's context here, so let's fix that.  It's absolutely correct to say that life begins before birth.  The definition of 'life' in this context is not the same as 'life' in the context of an actual, live human.  It's signifying the same thing as the previous quotes in this article: it's when fertilization happens, when a body can be allowed to form.  The fact that it then goes on to say that the embryo id est (i.e.), is literally the one example, demonstrates this casual use of the terms, as well as demonstrates that the fertilization isn't actually the same kind of beginning of life as an actual post-natal baby.  Moving on.

“In that fraction of a second when the chromosomes form pairs, the sex of the new child will be determined, hereditary characteristics received from each parent will be set, and a new life will have begun.”
From what I can tell, this is also correct.  It's literally part of the fertilization process.  However, it's also important to note that, apart from a few alleles pairing off into chromosomes, there's literally no sexual characteristics to this zygote, any more than there is a forehead, or a big toe.  These simply aren't things at this point.  It has the potential to develop those things, based upon this set of DNA instructions, but it certainly isn't male or female at this point. Unless, of course, you argue that the only determinant of sex is genetic (and not secondary/chemical/whatever).  The cell isn't producing it's own estrogen or testosterone, so it doesn't really matter what sex it is at this point.

Because it's a simple zygote.  It's not a human.  It can potentially become a human some day, but it's not one right now.

“It should always be remembered that many organs are still not completely developed by full-term and birth should be regarded only as an incident in the whole developmental process.”

Well, that's a wonderful point, but it doesn't tell us anything about the actual argument at hand.  Once a baby is cut free from the umbilical cord and is a breathing, vocalizing, thinking thing (though still perhaps not consciously), it's no longer an embryo.  Most people aren't taking the argument that babies are fetuses, and this article certainly isn't, so I'm not dwelling on this point too much.

I will, however, go so far as to say that a zygote has absolutely zero organs.  I will even go on further to remind our dear readers that, occasionally, some organs never fully develop.  However, the lack of fusion of your brain plate does not make you less human just because it's unfused.  That's literally one of the traits of a newly-born human.  Remember, your sexual organs probably didn't stop developing until you were in perhaps 4th-6th grade, but no one is arguing that a 12 year old is a fetus.  This might be important later.  Maybe not, I've not actually read any further than this so far.

“It is the penetration of the ovum by a sperm and the resulting mingling of nuclear material each brings to the union that constitutes the initiation of the life of a new individual.”
Again, I don't disagree with it.  However, the use of the word 'life' is typically different when we're talking about the development of an organism vs the organism itself.  For people who like to be ambiguous with terms, this shouldn't be a hard concept to grasp, especially when that ambiguity is usually removed in context.  However, I'm not even going to look up the context because this on even explicitly says 'initiation of the life of a new individual.'  It's commonly known that gestation takes 9 months.  That's a long initiation period, but nonetheless, there ya go.

“Although it is customary to divide human development into prenatal and postnatal periods, it is important to realize that birth is merely a dramatic event during development resulting in a change in environment.”
And again, from a clinical standpoint, this is a useful thing to demonstrate.  Also, it's worth noting that most late-term abortions are not the kinds of things mothers want.  Any fetus which has reached its third trimester is not the kind of fetus a mother typically wants to get rid of.  Usually this is done because of extenuating factors, like things that might kill both the mother and the child.  Aborting a late-term fetus to avoid a miscarriage which could kill the mother is not something the mother probably wants.  However, this is a topic for a different time, and I'm not going to address late-term abortions now.  The scope of the list of quotes I'm talking about doesn't seem to encompass it, so neither will I.  Maybe later, but not now.

“Your baby starts out as a fertilized egg… For the first six weeks, the baby is called an embryo.”
 Indeed, this is correct again.  A baby starts out as a fertilized cell, which then engages in mitosis to become (very rapidly) an embryo, for around the first to the eighth week.  This is no different than saying that a cake starts out as its constituent components.  If I remove a cake from my oven at the halfway point of baking, no one would call that a cake.  They might call it something that comes before a cake, but certainly not a cake.  I realize this analogy is a bit crude, but they're forcing my hand here.  It's hard to simplify things like this.  However, the analogy of a bun in the oven is ubiquitous, so blame it on that.  For this purpose, the zygote would be like putting all the stuff in the mixing bowl, the embryo would be like the actual act of mixing and all the stuff before it goes into the oven, and the fetus would be like its time in the oven.

I was going to put a picture of a birthday cake here.
Against my poorer judgement, I decided against it.
So, the rest of this article delves further and further into its own mess of an argument.  It repeats at least one quote, and starts quoting some pro-life stuff, none of which actually supports the argument it's making.  The main crux of it's arguments from here on out appears to be 'some people said life begins at conception so that means it's true.  It doesn't matter what the actual context is, because we don't care about context.  We only care about cherry-picking words that make us look better outside of context.'

I would go on, but I can tell this blog post is getting entirely too long.  Maybe I'll address some more of these issues later.  Probably not, but maybe.

Peace to you all!

Thursday, February 4, 2016

The future.

So, I've been hearing people talking a lot about things like minimum wage, (un)employment, working for a dollar, and the claim that we'll always need the current minimum wage jobs we have.  One of the sentiments I heard recently also questioned where the social security money goes for people who die before they can collect. However, most of our simple jobs are going to be replaced by computers and robots soon enough.    CGP Grey laid out some of the basics in his video a while back, and I'd like to take a moment to put my thoughts to pen as well.

Well, not so much a pen, as a keyboard.
The future is approaching, and it's probably best we deal with it. The fact that you're reading this is a pretty clear indication that I don't need a newspaper anymore to facilitate this kind of information transfer.  That's a thing I would have needed perhaps 30 years ago to do a blog like this.  This removes, at minimum, three jobs.  The typesetter is no longer needed, that's me (or the computer, if you like).  The delivery person isn't needed nearly so much anymore, as fewer people are buying newspapers in general.  Similarly, it means no one is paying me for this article.  Sir Arthur Conan Doyle certainly got paid for his stories.  I'm not a freelance writer, I'm simply a guy with a blog, and it's reaching your eyes.  MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!

Thinking about this in the forward perspective lends us a new understanding of our place.  Soon, kiosks will be eliminating the need for cashiers and clerks.  You may have even seen these already in your local grocery store, fast food place, soda or snack machine, theater, or even on your phone or computer.

That's a picture from Taco Bell's website.
Fair use since I'm discussing the digital application!
They aren't paying me for this endorsement.
I just really like tacos.
Now, let's talk about the economics for a minute, since that's what it boils down to.  When you visit a place (or place an order) with somewhere that has an option to bypass humans, you're effectively voting, with your money and time, that this is something you want.  Ever ordered a ticket online, instead of in person?  Maybe you've used the self-checkouts at Walmart, or other big box stores.  Perhaps you make a lot of purchases from Amazon or Ebay that you could otherwise make in person, somewhere local.  These are all indicators that (among other things, like price) you support a human-less exchange system.  No longer do you need to pay someone to wait on you, you can simply order the thing and pick it up.  In some cases, you can even have a drone deliver it to your door.


Let's jump forward perhaps ten years.  Driverless cars will be here, and will be gaining some serious footing.  Imagine, you pull up your Uber app, and a car with no driver picks you up.  Since the car doesn't have to be piloted by someone, it can be driven any time, day or night.  No person means no salary, and potentially a savings to you, the consumer.

Maybe you can see a problem already.  Fewer jobs to be done by people means that fewer people will be making money.  Regardless of how much I might like to work, if I can't be competitive, I'm not going to make any money.  Sure, there's going to be some jobs that only humans can do, probably even for the next two hundred years.  However, the number of jobs that don't require a human has increased drastically in the past 30 years or so.  This means fewer people making money, and therefore fewer people spending it.

It is therefore my prediction that a sort of socialist society will, by necessity, grow out of it.  It won't make sense to pay a small fraction of the population to work, when the rest of the population will have no money to spend on things.  Eventually, the system will have to allow most people to live in some other kind of economy.  In fact, I can imagine that even within my lifetime, the average work week may well be decreased per person, in favor of employing as many people as possible.  Spreading the work around isn't a bad idea.  Imagine if you could have all the benefits of working, and so could your neighbor, and neither of you have to work over 20 hours a week, perhaps.

Of course, this is quite a way from being a reality.  The problem right now is that we simply don't have as many jobs available as we did in the past, and we've got more people who are able to do those jobs.  Simple supply and demand demonstrates that we'll have a problem.  Factor in various things like inflation, growing numbers of retirees, and the fact that the economy is not designed to not include people, and we've got a wonderful set of problems we are going to have to rectify soon.

Well, we don't have to, but the problems aren't going to solve themselves.  Ignoring this is a solution, one which will lead to inevitable collapse of our current society and economy.  We've seen failed economies before, but at this rate, it's going to be a new kind of failure.  Perhaps WWIII will be fought in economics, rather than traditional weapons.  Do we really want to wait until the last minute to find out it's the only option left?

Saturday, January 23, 2016

Strategic Butt Coveting

This is something of a rebuttal to Feminist Frequency's latest video.  It's interesting that Anita has such a myopic view of what kinds of games she'll review.  Of all the video games she could have chosen, she strategically missed some of the largest, most mainstream games currently available (and also previously available, at earlier points in time).

Let's look at the most obvious candidates.  GTA 5 comes to mind, as does Fallout 4.  GTA 5 is particularly interesting, because it's had phenomenal success and is one of the most easily recognizable games in circulation.  One of the main characters that can be played frequently finds himself nearly naked, showing no shortage of derriere. For someone as supposedly egalitarian feminist as her, this seems a huge oversight.  Why isn't she decrying the objectification of any butt, if female butts are equal to male butts?

Moving on to Fallout 4, another powerhouse gaming experience.  Quite possibly, it's the most popular game in the world.  It's still in the top ten or so games sold weekly.  The protagonist can be either male or female, and the player has the full choice of how much the character is exposed, and even whether or not to play in third person view.  Anita would have us believe that these games she is reviewing are on par with the games that are actually at the forefront of gaming culture.

Of course, Anita doesn't really understand the demographic she's trying to persuade.  When I play a video game, for example, I don't pay much attention to my character.  That is, unless my character's actions have some bearing on the overall story.  Much like Kenneth, I like to be whatever character I am playing.  If the choices I make are plot-specific, then by all means the character could be significant.  However, Anita's complete ignorance of the companies that are doing equality (by her definition) correctly, is something of a major oversight.  Instead, she's complaining that characters are acting in character.  Simultaneously, Anita pretends that Lara Croft's butt is important because it's representing a human ideal, while ignoring the fact that Lara Croft's character should be afforded the same rights.  Lara's character is the actions she's taking on screen, from the clothes she wears to the actions she does.  Her sense of adventure, strong will, and good protagonist characteristics are thrown out the window by Anita.  This is the main reason Anita's argument fails, because she fails to realize that the character must be taken as a whole.

In this way, Anita is a considerably worse objectifier than any of the myriad people who play the games.  She's acting like a physical attribute is what defines the person.  As she said, we can't know what the character is by looking at its butt, but it's the only part of the character upon which she chooses to make her judgments on the character.  Never mind whether the character would actually choose to act that way, for it is impossible for Anita to see these characters as anything other than their outward appearance, to objectify them as their supposedly ill-proportioned bodies.

Although Anita won't understand this, lots of us don't judge a character by whether or not that character shows some skin.  Anita does, and presumes that the designers have no other motives at play.  Using Lara again, the point of her character is to be loud, showy, strong, and over the top.  It's only logical that, being what her character is, she would be presented in such a way.  In exactly the same way, Batman wears a type of armor that makes his muscles seem ill-proportioned, because he wants to give an intimidating vibe.  It's not for a show of sexuality that Bruce Wayne chooses a rather mesomorphic costume; his ploy is not to be a sex symbol.  By Anita's logic, batman is simply an object the designers are making for straight cis women to be aroused by.  Clearly, one can see the flaw in this line of reasoning.  Batman chooses a bulky appearance for the same reason Spiderman chooses a lanky one, or Rorschach chooses to be an enigma hidden behind a layer of thick clothing.

That's my rebuttal to her poor choice of logic.  Now, if only I could make a million dollars a year debunking her, like she makes spreading her vitriol.  One can dream...

Asexuality

I am currently having an interesting conversations in the comments section of an image on Imgur, regarding asexuality.  Being a person who is, I've also been asked a few questions and given a few anecdotes over my time.  Now, I shall take a moment to explain a few things, whereby I shall expound after.  This might become a two-part blog post, maybe more, since people do seem to like my shorter blog posts better.  I suppose that's all about digestion, eh?

Also, as this is about sexuality, or lack thereof, the content might be a bit more mature than other subjects.  If anything related to this sort of discussion may be unfavorable reading material to you, I completely understand, and suggest you stop reading now. Not everyone likes to discuss or read this sort of thing, but it's for education, so come on a journey with me.

Let's start with the dictionary definition, using google.  You can have google define words for you by typing something like this into the search box.
define:asexual
So, using the first definition of asexual, we find it is defined as a lack of sexual feelings or associations.  The second definition deals with a biological definition, regarding things which reproduce without sex.  It's important to make this distinction, since you were probably taught only the latter in science class.  Bacteria reproduce that way, for example.  However, we're using the first definition, because humans are biologically sexual creatures.  Some humans like myself, however, lack the desire (or in some cases, even find it undesirable) to have sex.  Let's try to relate this to the readers who don't understand.  It's understandable if one doesn't, given one's sexuality.

It's simplest for me to explain it like this.  Cats are cute, and so are women, but I don't have a desire to have sex with either.  I don't have the desire to have sex as a sexual person apparently does.  I do like the aesthetic of a body I find attractive, but it's exactly the same kind of aesthetic as I find in a car, color, shape or animal that I find attractive.  Perhaps 'attractive' isn't the best word, but I think the best word is a lacuna (define:lacuna) and so I'm going to use it.  The word will mean, in this context, something I find pleasing to behold, like good music or a neat painting.  I am therefore attracted to things I find pleasing (visually, let's say) in exactly the same way as anyone else.  Imagine something you think looks good, which isn't something with which you want to have sex.  That's all the further attraction works in my head.

I realize that's a bit to comprehend, so let that soak in a moment.  Let's step back a bit, and consider the more basic argument.  I may have gotten ahead of myself, but I think this will bring it full-circle.  No sexual desire typically means that an asexual person doesn't want to have sex, but that doesn't mean the person won't.  I find, for example, that I'm not terribly interested in what most people would consider typically sexual behavior, like kissing, hugging, holding hands, &c.  I simply don't care for them.  For our purposes, things like this will be called romantic behaviors.  Even that attraction above can be considered a romantic sort of inclination, albeit in a different way (again, see lacuna).  There are people, like myself, who simply don't care for that sort of thing, also.

People like to tell me that I simply haven't found the right person, or that perhaps the right person will come along some day.  I can say with some certainty that this probably isn't the case.  Being both asexual and aromantic, I'm literally quite content to simply have friends and be single for the entirety of my life.  This isn't to say that I would flatly turn down someone who was interested in me, but there would be considerable conversation before I would let a person into such a relationship with myself.  It would be unfair, I presume, to bring a sexual romantic into a relationship with myself.  This isn't the case for everyone.  Some people are completely content to simply engage in sexual behavior on the other person's behalf.  I'm not intrigued by that idea, so I don't approach it.  Even further, it's not something I want, in the same ways I presume a straight man is not interested in other men.

Which brings me to another interesting bit about myself.  I would call myself a 'straight' asexual, although that term probably doesn't mean the same thing to me as it does to the average 'straight' person.  In general, the average female form is a bit more aesthetically pleasing (comely?) than the average male form.  However, and this must be stressed, I don't care to have sex with anyone.  That's all that asexual means.  I only bring up this section because people ask about it sometimes.  It's obviously redundant to use 'straight' to mean 'heterosexual' in this way, because a 'heterosexual asexual' is a redundant term.  It simply doesn't make sense, and that's why I've taken the careful liberty of explaining it separately here.

Similarly, please keep in mind that these are my experiences alone.  Other asexuals will possibly identify differently in these ways. In fact, asexuality.org has lots of people who identify as non-typical sexualities and romanticisms.  If you think you might be among this group, or someone you know is, definitely check that out.  It will answer your more generic and more specific questions reasonably.

I'd like to make one final point before I end this post. Desires and urges are two different things in this way of thinking.  Occasionally, I have a need to relieve the such an urge, but there's no desire connected with it.  It's not so different from when one needs to urinate. I'm trying to keep this as polite as possible, mind you.  I simply take care of that urge, and go on with my life.  Usually this happens when my dreams start to become strange, presumably from the buildup of various hormones.  This is typically what prompts me to such action.  There is no sexual desire involved, merely an urge like needing to eat, or use the bathroom.  I've never had sex, and I've got no desire to do so.  I don't even have a desire to do what I must occasionally, but the urge is biological.  I similarly have no real desire to urinate, but occasionally I have the urge to eliminate urine from my body.  Semen is no different, to me.  In a sexual person, it's quite a different kind of thing.

It's not that I don't understand desires.  Every once in a while, I will get a craving for a particular kind of food, or to play a particular board game or video game.  Those are very much real desires.  I reckon that some people want sexuality in the same way that I want a really good dinner.  This isn't being dismissive of sexuality, mind you.  I'm not trying to defend or break down either viewpoint.  I'm merely showing what I see to be evidently true.  There's no shame in realizing one's sexuality, or lack thereof.  If you enjoy something, and it's not hurting anyone, then fully enjoy it!

I will post a second part eventually.  I need to get some good food now!